+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Treasury Money Funds Shun New Investors to Protect Yields, Fees
2008-12-04 18:10:18.780 GMT
By Miles Weiss and Christopher Condon
Dec. 4 (Bloomberg) -- Money-market mutual funds that buy
mostly U.S. Treasuries are starting to turn away new investors
as the lowest yields on government debt in 50 years pull down
returns for shareholders and squeeze managers’ fees.
At least three Treasury money-market funds run by JPMorgan
Chase & Co., Evergreen Investments and Allegiant Asset
Management recently stopped taking outside cash, according to
Web site notices and regulatory filings. Barring new customers
protects returns for investors already in the funds because
managers don’t have to buy as many new Treasuries with yields
lower than current holdings. Higher fund yields also prop up
management fees.
Yields on three-month Treasury bills approached zero this
week, driven by demand from investors fleeing falling stock and
bond markets and anticipating more rate cuts as the Federal
Reserve seeks to revive the economy. Yields have dropped so fast
that Treasury money funds now have higher returns than
Treasuries, helping to more than double assets to $286 billion
in the past three months.
“These are clearly extraordinary circumstances,” said
Peter Crane, president of Crane Data LLC, a money-fund research
firm in Westborough, Massachusetts. “Normally, you don’t see
differences between the direct market and the money funds that
are enough to move the needle.”
As of Tuesday, institutional money market funds that invest
in Treasuries and related repurchase agreements had an average
seven-day yield of 0.17 percent or 17 basis points, down from
160 basis points at the beginning of September, according to
iMoneyNet, another Westborough research firm. At current levels,
a $1,000 investment would earn $1.70 over the course of a year.
Lower Yields
Treasury bills that mature in three months have a current
annual yield of about 6 basis points, according to Bloomberg
data. Money-market funds that take in new cash would have to buy
Treasuries at these levels, dragging down their overall payout.
“We just want to maintain a yield that ensures fairness to
all the investors in the fund,” said Laura Fay, a spokeswoman
for Evergreen. The company has offices in Boston and Charlotte,
North Carolina, the headquarters of parent Wachovia Corp.
According to Dec. 1 notices, the Evergreen Institutional
100% Treasury Money Market Fund, which had assets of $1.9
billion at Sept. 30, and Allegiant Treasury Money Market Fund,
with about $1.3 billion under management, both temporarily
closed to new investors. Allegiant Asset Management is a unit of
Cleveland-based National City Corp.
Some Treasury funds closed to new investors in September,
the last time yields plummeted, only to reopen later, said Peter
Rizzo, director of fund services at Standard & Poor’s in New
York.
‘Flooded With Money’
The $42.7 billion JPMorgan 100% U.S. Treasury Securities
Money Market Fund has remained closed to new purchases since
Oct. 2, fund manager Wendy Fletcher said in an interview.
“We were just flooded with money,” said Fletcher, whose
fund offered a 0.06 percent return on its most expensive share
class as of yesterday, down from 3.11 percent a year ago,
according to data compiled by Bloomberg. “I can’t remember
seeing this kind of market ever.”
JPMorgan’s decision was also influenced by concern that the
torrent of investors might reverse, forcing the fund to sell
securities at a loss to meet redemptions, Fletcher said. While
the fund has come under pressure from investors to reopen, it
will stay shut into next year, she said.
“We knew that if we opened the fund it would get another
flood because people want to get extra clean for year-end,” she
said, referring to the desire of corporate investors to show
liquid balance sheets when they report to shareholders.
Goldman Sachs Fund
An online trading portal run by Dallas-based Comerica Inc.
yesterday listed the JPMorgan fund and Goldman Sachs FS Treasury
Instruments Fund as being closed to new investors. The notice
was taken down by 3 p.m. New York time.
Melissa Daly, a spokeswoman for Goldman Sachs, said the fund
was open to investors and declined to comment on why the
Comerica Web site had listed the fund as closed.
The stampede into Treasuries began with this year’s credit
crunch and accelerated after Sept. 16, when the $62.5 billion
Reserve Primary Fund announced that its losses on debt issued by
the bankrupt Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. would push its net
asset value below $1 a share. It was the first time in 14 years
that a money-market fund had dropped under that level, marring
the industry’s reputation as the safest investment category
after bank deposits and U.S. Treasuries.
Over the ensuing three weeks, institutions yanked about
$347 billion out of prime money markets that invest in corporate
debt and plowed almost $300 billion into those that hold only
U.S. government paper, according to iMoneyNet.
Fed Action
The growth in Treasury funds was slowed in November by
declining yields and increasing investor acceptance of prime
funds that held corporate debt backed by the U.S. government
under new federal bailout programs.
Government money-market funds might continue to face
falling Treasury yields as the Fed seeks to revive the economy.
Fed Chairman Ben S. Bernanke said Dec. 1 that further cuts in
the central bank’s benchmark interest rate are feasible. The Fed
might begin to buy back longer-term Treasuries, he said. That
step would raise prices and push down yields.
If the Fed keeps reducing rates, asset-management firms
will have to decide whether to waive their management fees for
Treasury funds “to keep yields in positive territories,” said
Rizzo, the S&P analyst.
Some money-market funds that invest in Treasuries may seek
to increase their yields by delving into bank debt backed by the
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, Crane said.
FDIC
Companies such as Goldman Sachs, Morgan Stanley and
JPMorgan have sold $38.6 billion of government-backed bonds
since Nov. 21, when the FDIC strengthened its Temporary
Liquidity Guarantee Program to ensure timely payment of
principal and interest in the event of default.
Douglas Scheidt, an associate director in the SEC’s
investment-management division, said in an interview that he has
received calls from lawyers representing money-market funds
asking whether the FDIC-backed debt would qualify as government
securities.
“From what we can tell, the FDIC guarantee would be a
government guarantee, so it would be a government security,”
said Scheidt, whose division regulates money market funds.
For Related News:
On Money Market Funds: NI FND <GO>
ON JPMorgan: JPM US <Equity> DES <GO>
--Editors: Matthew Keenan, Larry Edelman
To contact the reporters on this story:
Miles Weiss in Washington at +1-202-624-1899 or
[email protected];
Christopher Condon in Boston at +1-617-210-4633 o
[email protected]To contact the editor responsible for this story
Larry Edelman at +1-617-210-4621 or
[email protected]