+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Emerging Markets Most Expensive Since ’07 as Funds Get Flooded
2009-06-01 22:10:34.474 GMT
By Patricia Lui and Michael Patterson
June 2 (Bloomberg) -- The four-week flood of money into
developing-nation stock funds that drove the MSCI Emerging
Markets Index to an eight-month high is sending the strongest
sell signal since equities peaked in October 2007.
Inflows totaled $12 billion, or 3.5 percent of developing-
nation fund assets, the most since the 22-country benchmark hit
its record high 19 months ago, said EPFR Global, which tracks
$10 trillion in investments worldwide. The only other time since
2001 that funds attracted as much cash, in February 2006, the
MSCI gauge lost 8.4 percent in four months.
The pattern signals an “imminent” drop after the MSCI
index’s 3.8 percent rally yesterday pushed its advance since
February to a record 61 percent, according to Michael Hartnett,
a Bank of America-Merrill Lynch strategist who predicted this
year’s gains in Chinese, Brazilian and Russian shares. A slower-
than-estimated economic recovery in China, the largest emerging
market, may spark a retreat, said RBC Capital Markets.
“Fund flows at their extremes are contrary indicators,”
Leo Grohowski, who helps oversee about $132 billion as the New
York-based chief investment officer at BNY Mellon Wealth
Management, said in an interview. “We’re looking for some
consolidation.”
BlackRock Inc., the biggest publicly traded asset manager
in the U.S., and Aberdeen Asset Management Plc, Scotland’s
largest independent money manager, also are forecasting a
downturn after the MSCI index’s price-to-earnings ratio almost
doubled this year. The gauge trades for 15.3 times reported
profits, the most expensive level since December 2007, according
to weekly data compiled by Bloomberg.
Doubting the Rally
“Investors are starting to doubt the sustainability of how
much longer this very sharp rally can continue without a
pullback,” said Brad Durham, the co-founder and managing
director at Cambridge, Massachusetts-based EPFR Global.
“Valuations are not as attractive.”
The MSCI index dropped 48 percent in the second half of
2008, while emerging-market bonds lost 18 percent and every
major currency except China’s yuan retreated against the dollar.
Treasuries returned 11 percent in the same period as investors
sought the highest-rated assets, according to Merrill Lynch’s
U.S. Treasury Master Index.
More than $12 trillion pledged by the U.S. government to
ease the global recession, along with $1 trillion of aid from
international organizations to bolster developing economies,
prompted investors to reverse their trades this year. The MSCI
emerging-market index’s rally the past three months was the
biggest since its inception in December 1987 and beat the 29
percent rise in the MSCI World Index of developed-nation shares.
Dollar Drops
The dollar lost 2.7 percent against a basket of six major
currencies this year, while U.S. government securities dropped
4.3 percent through last week in their worst annual start since
Merrill began tracking returns in 1978.
HSBC Private Bank’s Arjuna Mahendran said the surge in
emerging-market equities may last another six months as faster
economic growth in developing countries prompts investors to
keep shifting out of lower-yielding assets.
Developing nations will grow 1.6 percent as a group in 2009
and 4 percent next year, according to the Washington-based
International Monetary Fund, which was formed after World War II
to help stabilize member countries’ economies. That compares
with IMF estimates for a 3.8 percent contraction in developed
economies this year and no growth in 2010.
Yesterday’s rally in emerging-market stocks was sparked by
a report showing Chinese manufacturing expanded for a third
month in May, fueling speculation that the world’s third-largest
economy is recovering.
Money-Market Funds
Bullish money managers say that emerging-market stocks will
keep gaining as investors shift some of the $3.8 trillion in
money-market funds into equities. The funds, which aim to
preserve capital without targeting high returns, hold about 60
percent more assets than the average this decade, according to
the Washington-based Investment Company Institute.
“There’s a lot of money looking for decent returns and
that’s going to continue driving emerging markets,” said
Mahendran, the Singapore-based chief investment strategist for
Asia at HSBC Private Bank, which oversaw $352 billion as of the
end of last year. “They are the only place on earth where any
growth is taking place.”
‘Bubble-Like’ Rush
Merrill’s Hartnett said the long-term outlook for gains in
developing-nation economies and equities may not warrant the
“bubble-like” rush into emerging-market stocks the past few
months. For Jonathan Garner, a Morgan Stanley strategist, the
surge in fund flows shows a “euphoria” among investors seen
before previous market peaks.
Investors poured $19 billion into emerging-market stock
funds in the four weeks to Oct. 17, 2007, EPFR data show. The
MSCI gauge began tumbling from a record 1,338.49 two weeks
later, losing as much as 22 percent during the next four months.
Garner, Morgan Stanley’s London-based head of Asian and
emerging-market strategy, is advising clients to reduce holdings
of stocks from developing countries to buy later at lower
prices.
Even though developing-nation economies are expanding,
earnings at companies in the MSCI emerging-markets gauge trailed
analysts’ estimates by an average of 41 percent in the first
quarter, a wider miss than the 6.7 percent average in MSCI’s
developed markets gauge, Bloomberg data show.
Analysts predict shares in the emerging index will fall 2.9
percent in the next 12 months on average, compared with a 3.4
percent gain for developed markets, according to estimates
compiled by Bloomberg.
Stalled Recovery
China’s economic recovery began to stall in the second half
of April and slowed further in May, raising concern that the
rebound won’t be as “strong as many recently have hoped,” Dong
Tao, Credit Suisse Group AG’s Hong Kong-based economist, wrote
in a report last month. He cited weaker electronics and retail
industries and a slump in power consumption.
While the expansion in China’s manufacturing suggests an
economic rebound in the second half of this year, investors
shouldn’t expect a “straight-line” recovery, said Nick Chamie,
the global head of emerging markets research at RBC in Toronto.
Lower exports and a delayed increase in Chinese consumer
spending may spur “mixed” economic data in the coming months
and cause declines in emerging-market assets, he said.
China stock funds attracted the most money among the
biggest emerging markets this year, taking in $3.6 billion. That
compares with the $2.8 billion added into Brazilian funds, $483
million into India and $410 million into Russia, the three other
biggest developing-nation economies, the EPFR data show.
China Stimulus
Investors lured to China by the government’s 4 trillion
yuan ($586 billion) stimulus package spurred a 49 percent rally
in the benchmark Shanghai Composite Index this year. The gauge
trades for 21 times analysts’ estimates for 2009 earnings, the
second-highest among major emerging markets worldwide after
Taiwan, according to Bloomberg data.
BlackRock, which oversees about $1.3 trillion, pared
holdings in China and Taiwan this year on concern prices rose
too fast, said Bob Doll, the New York-based money manager’s vice
chairman and global chief investment officer of equities.
Emerging markets may lead a “correction,” or decline of about
10 percent, in stocks worldwide before recovering later this
year, he said.
Aberdeen Managing Director Hugh Young is selling some
financial stocks and buying “defensive” shares including
Jakarta-based tobacco company Pt BAT Indonesia on expectations
companies with stable revenue will outperform during a selloff.
“Stock markets have rallied too strongly,” said Young,
who helps oversee about $35 billion of Asian assets for Aberdeen
in Singapore. “We are far from being out of the woods.”
For Related News and Information:
Emerging-market news: NI EM <GO>
For emerging-market stocks news: TNI EM STK <GO>
Developing economy market moves: EMMV <GO>
Emerging-market economic statistics STAT4 <GO>
Top emerging-market stories: TOP EM <GO>
--With reporting by Chen Shiyin in Singapore. Editors: Sandy
Hendry, Phil Kuntz.
To contact the reporters on this story:
Patricia Lui in Singapore at +65-6499-2658 or
[email protected];
Michael Patterson in London at +44-20-7073-3102 or
[email protected].
To contact the editors responsible for this story:
Sandy Hendry at +85-2-2977-6608 or
[email protected];
David Papadopoulos at +1-212-617-5105 or
[email protected].