+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
Fines for CPI Researchers Fueling Bond Slump: Argentina Credit
2011-02-09 16:44:30.213 GMT
By Camila Russo and Eliana Raszewski
Feb. 9 (Bloomberg) -- Argentine inflation-linked bonds are
posting their first monthly decline since June as the government
threatens to fine research companies that don’t reveal how they
estimate price increases that are double the official rate.
The Economy Ministry issued a letter last week asking for
information including where the companies collect their data and
how many products they track, according to Buenos Aires-based
Finsoport and Ecolatina. Failure to provide the data will result
in a fine, according to the letter.
The threats are curbing speculation that President Cristina
Fernandez de Kirchner’s government will bring its inflation
figures closer to the 23 percent annual rate calculated by
Finsoport and 26.4 percent by Ecolatina. Official data shows
prices rose 10.9 percent last year. Argentine inflation-linked
bonds lost 2 percent in the past 30 days, trailing gains of 0.8
percent on similar Brazilian debt and 0.9 percent on Chilean
notes tied to consumer prices, according to Barclays Plc.
“Last week’s measure was a strong signal and fueled
investors to sell these instruments and chose better
alternatives,” said Javier Salvucci, a money manager at Silver
Cloud Advisors in Buenos Aires. “Expectations of an attitude
change are low after the government’s latest actions. I don’t
see a substantial change to the inflation measurements in the
short and middle term.”
The letter and list of questions, which also went to
Orlando Ferreres y Asociados, said the research companies had 48
hours to respond and threatened them with fines of as much as
500,000 pesos ($125,000) if they didn’t cooperate.
Data Methodologies
The government wants to make the research companies’
methodologies more transparent, said an official at the Economy
Ministry who declined to be identified because he isn’t allowed
to speak publicly on the issue. Presidential spokesman Alfredo
Scoccimarro didn’t respond to messages left on his mobile phone
seeking comment. A press official at the National Statistics
Agency, known as Indec, declined to comment.
Norberto Itzcovich, the head of Indec, has said the
official data is accurate and that private economists aren’t
capable of gathering information as extensively as the
government and should make their procedures public.
Jorge Todesca, a former deputy economy minister who heads
Finsoport, said his company didn’t answer the questions and
asked to be told about the legal basis on which the government
requested the information. The government authorized Finsoport
to see its legal documents and postponed the deadline, he said.
‘Intimidate the People´
“The government is looking to discredit private
consultants’ measurements, to intimidate the people who make
these measurements and those who provide information,” Todesca
said. “After looking at the file we’ll see if we answer or
resort to another mechanism.”
Ecolatina didn’t answer the government’s questions and
responded by saying its methodology has been protected by
copyright since 2009 and by a professional confidentiality
agreement, according to Rodrigo Alvarez, the company’s economy
and finance manager.
The official data determine the return that holders of
inflation-linked bonds receive, making the numbers critical for
investors.
Argentina asked the International Monetary Fund on Nov. 23
to help the government devise a consumer price index that
reflects regional differences in consumption. Inflation-linked
bonds returned 5.8 percent since that date to the end of 2010 as
investors bet the government would report faster inflation. The
yield on the notes was 7.383 percent yesterday, up from 6.734
percent at the end of 2010, according to Barclays.
Official Data
“The market overestimated the willingness of the current
administration to publish more accurate inflation data,” said
Boris Segura, a Latin America economist at Nomura Securities
International Inc. in New York. “After the pressure on the
consultants it is becoming clearer that this administration, at
least before the election, is doing nothing about this.”
Fernandez said today in a speech at the presidential palace
that some businesses are raising prices to boost profits, not to
offset higher costs.
“There’s a range of prices, distortions and some people
take advantage of that,” Fernandez said.
Economists have questioned the official inflation data
since 2007, when Fernandez’s late husband and predecessor as
president, Nestor Kirchner, began replacing personnel at Indec.
Fernandez, 57, hasn’t said whether she’ll run for re-election in
October.
Lack of Confidence
The lack of confidence in official reports led private
companies, including Finsoport and Abeceb.com, to start
reporting their own CPI in 2007. Graciela Bevacqua, who was
removed from her post as director of the statistics agency’s
consumer price index department under Kirchner in 2007, has been
releasing her own inflation data since mid-2008 at a research
department of the University of Buenos Aires.
“We were forced to come up with our own inflation numbers
using simpler methods because we have fewer resources, since the
official data stopped being trustworthy,” Todesca said in a
telephone interview.
Argentine debt linked to consumer prices is under
performing because protests in Egypt and the fear of political
turmoil spreading throughout the region damped demand for Latin
America’s riskiest assets, according to Eduardo Suarez, an
emerging-markets strategist at RBC in Toronto.
“It’s hard to differentiate what is pure risk sell-out
from what we saw on the past couple of weeks on the global
basis,” Suarez said in a telephone interview. “They sell off
more when there is a risk like what we saw during the last
couple of weeks because of Egypt.”
Treasuries Spread
The extra yield investors demand to hold Argentine dollar
bonds instead of U.S. Treasuries rose 11 basis points to 524 as
of 11:41 a.m. New York time, according to JPMorgan Chase & Co.
The cost of protecting Argentine debt against non-payment
for five years with credit-default swaps rose five basis points
yesterday to 585, according to data provider CMA in New York.
Credit-default swaps pay the buyer face value in exchange for
the underlying securities or the cash equivalent should a
government or company fail to adhere to debt agreements.
Warrants linked to growth in South America’s second-biggest
economy fell 0.32 cent to 15.1 cents, according to data compiled
by Bloomberg.
The peso rose 0.1 percent to 4.0157 per dollar.
Inflation-linked bonds may be attractive once prices return
to the levels they were before the government sought the IMF’s
help on its price index, Nomura’s Segura said.
“We are pricing out the wildest market expectations --that
with the coming of the IMF the inflation problem would be
solved,” Segura said. “When we price that out, these bonds
become interesting again.”
For Related News and Information:
Top Credit Market stories: TOP CM <GO>
Top Argentina stories: ARG <GO>
Argentine money markets monitor: BTMM AR <GO>
Argentine economic statistics: ECST AR <GO>
--Editors: Bill Faries, Brendan Walsh
To contact the reporters on this story:
Camila Russo in New York at 212-318-2000 or
[email protected];
Eliana Raszewski in Buenos Aires at +54-11-4321-7739 or
[email protected]To contact the editor responsible for this story:
David Papadopoulos at +1-212-617-5105 or
[email protected]