+------------------------------------------------------------------------------+
VIX Tracking Junk Lets PNC See S&P 500 Gains as Pimco Says Not!
2010-03-01 00:00:15.0 GMT
By Lynn Thomasson, Rita Nazareth and Jeff Kearns
March 1 (Bloomberg) -- Just when U.S. consumer confidence
is dropping and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke says
the economy is too fragile to raise interest rates, the options
market shows investing in stocks is getting safer.
The Chicago Board Options Exchange Volatility Index, which
measures the price of insuring equities against losses, trades
below the average over its 20-year history, according to data
compiled by Bloomberg. Investors in high-yield bonds demand
interest that is 6.57 percentage points more than Treasuries, 57
percent less than a year ago, data from Barclays Plc show.
For E. William Stone of PNC Wealth Management, declines in
measures of risk show shares will rally as earnings rise at the
fastest pace in a decade. Mohamed El-Erian, co-chief investment
officer for Pacific Investment Management Co., says falling
volatility means government spending is masking a stagnating
economy that will keep returns below average. The gauges last
fell to these levels in 2008, before the Standard & Poor’s 500
Index lost 56 percent.
“There’s still a tug-of-war out there,” said Stone, the
Philadelphia-based chief investment strategist at PNC, which
oversees $104 billion. “That’s what I would expect to happen.
Risk appetite has come back. We believe the recovery is
sustainable.”
Slower Advance
The S&P 500 slid 0.4 percent last week, extending its 2010
retreat to 1 percent, after consumer confidence dropped to the
lowest level since April and Bernanke said interest rates near
zero percent are needed to keep the economy growing. The
benchmark gauge for American equities has risen more than 60
percent over the past year as the U.S. government lent, spent or
guaranteed more than $8 trillion to end the longest recession
since the 1930s, data compiled by Bloomberg show.
The VIX, which moves in the opposite direction of stocks
more than 80 percent of the time, lost 2.6 percent to 19.5 for
its third straight weekly decrease. The gauge has averaged 20.3
since 1990. The BarCap U.S. Corporate High-Yield Average index
of spreads on company debt rated below Baa3 by Moody’s Investors
Service has fallen from a December 2008 record of 19.7
percentage points as bond prices rallied. The average for the
last nine years is 6.17 points, the data show.
The declines reflect confidence that earnings will push
shares higher, said Michael Shaoul, chairman of Marketfield
Asset Management, whose flagship fund beat 83 percent of its
peers last year. More than 72 percent of S&P 500 companies
reported fourth-quarter profits that beat the average analyst
forecast, Bloomberg data show. That’s the highest level after
the third quarter, when 80 percent topped projections.
Rising Earnings
Analysts predict operating income at S&P 500 companies will
rise 52 percent on average in the next two years, the biggest
increase since 1994, according to estimates compiled by
Bloomberg. Profits at financial companies are forecast to surge
112 percent in 2010.
“Both high-yield spreads and equity volatility are
sensitive to corporate earnings above all else, and regardless
of continuing macro-level fears these seem set for a period of
continued improvements,” Shaoul said in an interview from New
York. “Both indicators tell you we might be at the beginning of
a decent recovery.”
Greed is beating fear in the options market after El-Erian
warned last month that stock returns would trail the historical
average because investors have priced in too orderly a
withdrawal of government stimulus.
‘Restored Appetite’
The VIX and credit spreads “speak to the extent to which
government and Fed liquidity injections have restored appetite
for higher-risk assets,” El-Erian, who oversees $1 trillion for
Newport Beach, California-based Pimco, wrote in an e-mail. “The
key question going forward is whether fundamentals are
sufficiently strong to maintain these liquidity-driven
valuations.”
While volatility has fallen in 2010, options indicate more
probability of wider price swings. The cost of contracts that
protect against S&P 500 losses for two years has risen to the
highest level since November 2007, a month after U.S. stocks
peaked. Bearish options trade at 1.42 times the level for
bullish contracts, one of the highest readings in the last five
years, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.
Stock swings may increase as economic stimulus programs
expire and countries such as Greece struggle to close budget
deficits, said Matt McCormick at Bahl & Gaynor Inc. The S&P 500
has moved an average of 15 points a day this year, compared with
25 points for the same time in 2009, Bloomberg data show.
Conflicting Signals
Less stock volatility and lower junk-bond spreads have
preceded both rallies and bear markets this decade.
Improving profits and signs the economy was recovering
pushed the VIX and BarCap index down 36 percent and 54 percent
in 2003, when the S&P 500 gained 26 percent. The VIX ended
August 2008 at 20.65 while the payout on high-yield debt was
7.94 percentage points higher than Treasuries. Both surged after
the collapse of New York-based Lehman Brothers Holdings Inc. on
Sept. 15, 2008, with the VIX reaching a record 80.86 two months
later. The S&P 500 posted the worst year in seven decades.
“Investors right now have to choose which side of the
table they’re going to be on,” said McCormick, who helps
oversee $2.8 billion in Cincinnati. “Are they in the bullish
camp or the bearish camp? We’re in the camp where there’s going
to be more volatility.”
Speculation about the Fed’s plans for interest rates is
dividing investors after policy makers raised the rate charged
to banks for direct loans by a quarter-point to 0.75 percent on
Feb. 18. Bernanke said a week later that the U.S. economy is in
a “nascent” recovery that still requires a low Fed target rate
for overnight loans between banks, according to testimony before
the House Financial Services Committee in Washington on Feb. 24.
Rapid Change
The statement helped push down odds of an increase in the
Fed funds rate by August to 20 percent from 34.3 percent a week
ago, according to data on futures trading compiled by Bloomberg.
Investors are assigning a 47 percent chance to an increase by
November, down from 61 percent a week ago, the data show.
“The situation can change rapidly,” said Komal Sri-Kumar,
who helps manage $118 billion as chief global strategist at TCW
Group Inc. in Los Angeles. “If you’re taking advantage of the
low VIX or the high equity prices, would you be able to get out
the door fast enough when it turns? It’s the greater fool
theory. People are saying, ‘The situation is bad, but before it
gets really terrible I’ll be out.’ But you don’t know.”
For Related News and Information:
Spread comparison: VIX <Index> LF98OAS <Index> HS D <GO>
Market map of the S&P 500: SPX <Index> IMAP <GO>
Global heat map: MMAP <GO>
Most-active U.S. stocks: MOST US <GO>
Stories on U.S. stock options: NI USO <GO>
Equity screening: EQS <GO>
--With assistance from Nikolaj Gammeltoft in New York and Alexis
Xydias in London. Editors: Chris Nagi, Nick Baker
To contact the reporters on this story:
Lynn Thomasson in New York at +1-212-617-5346 or
[email protected];
Rita Nazareth in New York at +1-212-617-8908 or
[email protected];
Jeff Kearns in New York at +1-212-617-8138 or
[email protected].
To contact the editor responsible for this story:
Nick Baker at +1-212-617-5919 or
[email protected].