China's July data-dump was released this morning and we will discuss its various categories in three separate notes, the first dealing with credit data, the second monetary data and finally the economic activity measures for the month.
Of the three credit data would seem to be paramount, since it is most likely to drive future activity later this year and into 2014. As most readers will be aware the PBOC and new political administration have signaled a wish to constrain the role non-bank credit (or shadow banking) in the Chinese financial system and July's data mars the second month of very constrained non-bank financing.
Total Social (or Aggregate) Financing for July was 808.8 bln CNY ($132 bln), well below expectations of 925 bln CNY and June's level of 1,037 bln CNY (revised down from 1,040 bln CNY). This is the smallest level of Aggregate Financing since October 2011 and compares to a trailing 12 month ma of 1,491 bln CNY.
Bank Loans dominated Aggregate Financing making up 86.5% of the total at 699.9 bln CNY, close to the 12 month ma of 715 bln CNY and were above expectations of 640 bln CNY. Non-Bank Financing on the other hand plummeted to 108 bln CNY, its lowest level since September 2011 (when it actually contracted by -42.1 bln CNY) and this represents a decline of 92% from its March 2013 all time high.
In order to track this metric going forwards we are using a 6 month ma, which will smooth out the monthly fluctuations while soon eliminating some of the very powerful readings from early 2013. As of July this metric was 618 bln CNY, down from its April peak of 1025 bln, but still above its level last September during the run up to the explosion of shadow banking. We would suggest that 500 bln CNY demarcates "loose" from "tight" shadow banking, and base this on the average level of issuance since the start of 2009 (510 bln CNY). We therefore have had 2 tight months, but the large prior provision of credit is still having a beneficial effect.
In terms of the make-up of non bank credit we note that Bankers Acceptance Bills continued to contract at -178.3 bln CNY, the third consecutive month on shrinkage. Trust loan issuance was 107.4, down from 431.2 bln in March and 194 bln in April. We would ascribe this tightening directly to PBOC activity. However, in addition we note that corporate bond issuance has also collapsed, with July seeing a mere 46.1 bln CNY of issuance, a drop of 81% from activity in July 2012.
The destruction of the bond IPO market lies outside of the influence of the PBOC and has much more to do with the global rise in interest rates and reversal of previously rampant flows into emerging market fixed income (Chinese domestic flows were similarly enthusiastic earlier this year). It is important to understand that this represents a potent form of monetary tightening that is particularly relevant for corporate activity. If maintained for a number of months it threatens to impact both growth and credit performance.
In summary the July report meets our expectations. We are not surprised to see the official banking sector remain heavily active as a counterweight to the constraint on shadow banking. However, the sharp shrinkage of Aggregate Financing, if maintained for a number of months, can be expected to start to have a significant effect on portions of the Chinese economy going forwards. However, it will take a number of months for this to become apparent (we estimate at least 6 based on the experience of the US in 2007 after the sub-prime market shut down in late February), and the effects will be very unevenly spread throughout the economy.
On this basis market opinion got somewhat ahead of itself in early July, and we are not surprised to see a rebound in sentiment towards China now nothing bad has happened for a number of weeks. Again this is reminiscent of the "phony crisis" months of mid-2007 and we could continue to experience relatively calm conditions for a number of months longer before the market once more starts to obsess about the dangers of China's credit bubble.